Disappearing Students: the Miseducation of Romania’s Gypsies


The Roma enter an education system that is not predisposed to their success. The most evident indicator is the segregated schools and classrooms. Sometimes the segregation is purely geographic, as in a suburb of Craiova called Mofleni, where 90 % of the students in the elementary school are Roma. The school is mostly Roma for the same reason that Beverly Hills High is mostly white, but the poor school has inferior teachers and equipment. Other times, the segregation is forced. One 10th grade classroom that I attended in Baleni was almost entirely Roma. They were grouped there because they were “low performing,” and probably would not graduate high school. Romani Criss, in a study funded by UNICEF, found that 67 percent of the Roma were in segregated classes. Given the US’ own history with “separate but equal,” it’s not hard to imagine that the average Roma child, separated by geography or classroom, is offered an inferior education to the average white child.

Even if the students are mixed, the clash of cultures and mindsets creates a division in the classroom itself—Roma students always sit in the back. This was the case for all ten of the classes that I sat in on, in three different cities. The teachers treated them differently too. Marcela Rusu, an English teacher from Baleni who had dedicated herself to the school and its pupils for 16 years, described her frustrations. “It’s hard to reach them. They won’t do their exercises or their homework. They are lazy.”

Cezara of Romani Criss offered a different side of the story. “The school is not a welcoming environment. The teachers are not trained to teach a class where the children are different.” Cezara argues that teachers don’t go out of their way to accommodate some of the special needs of the Roma children. This has an impact from the earliest years of primary school, because many of the Romani children did not get a preschool or kindergarten education. (The state does not pay for that schooling). Often, they never fully catch up.

The Romani suffer from other disadvantages as well. They are more likely to miss school and fall behind on lessons, and often do not have access to the private tutors that many of their classmates enjoy. It takes special attention and work to bring those kinds of students up to speed. The teachers, who make around 200 euros a month, don’t have the time or interest to do so. As the education system fails them, many parents and children don’t see the value of school as higher than the opportunity cost of their work. The dropout count tallies, and a cycle of poverty and undereducation perpetuates the problem.

But the problem of the Roma’s high dropout rates does not lay on the shoulders of the school system alone—the Roma tend to place less value on education than ethnic Romanians. Some of this stems from the fact that the parents themselves are not educated. The Criss-UNICEF study found that 20% of parents with at least one school dropout could not read and write, and less than 15 percent had finished middle school. It’s not always poverty that’s forcing them out of school either.

Some simply don’t believe that going past middle school will help them make more money or lead to a better life. With 44 percent unemployment among the Roma community (source: World Bank), and a tradition of discrimination among employers and government, few dream of being able to land a top job. “The biggest problem is that they have no role models” said professor Sarau. Maybe, but Liviu of Craiova thinks it’s a discrimination problem. “Everywhere I apply [for a job], they turn me away because I am a gypsy.”

JournalismPermalink

3 Responses to Disappearing Students: the Miseducation of Romania’s Gypsies

  1. pH says:

    Fabulous! Loved the surprise of the first Post’One issue..The format inflates a piqued curiosity: effective video fly-over spreads out the story for perusal ( I dig the gypsy reprise of the theme music)…an opening paragraph opens the door into a deeper look while faces from the culture greet the visitor and invite future visits. Outstanding literary lay-out of a controversial situation, with memorable photography. This first issue provides a window into the future of “feature story” publishing.

    Bravo! I raise my glass to Postulate One, its two stars, and their production support team. Thank you for the bold web refreshment.
    Merci, vă mulţumesc!

  2. Scott says:

    As I was reading your great article, I was anxious to see what your concluding thoughts would be about possible solutions to the divide, and if you would come back to Cezara David’s comments.

    I think you’re spot on with your analyze of what one of the biggest issue is… integration and the Roma’s values.

    I know many casual observers would simply attribute the rift to the lack of opportunity or the financial inequality that they see. “Fix that”, many say, and all will be well. I think your ending thought is a much more astute observation and show than you were able to get a better understanding of the culture and values at play here. Refreshing.

    Ever read any of Lawrence Harrison’s essays? He’s a Harvard Professor and former director of the U.S. Agency for International Development in Guatemala, Haiti, Nicaragua and Costa Rica. In his recent book, he tackles the question of why some nations and ethnic groups prosper while others stagnate, in particularly North America versus Latin America, who both had tremendous raw materials.

    He finds the answer in a culture’s values. In his analysis, he comments on Mexico’s economic disaster and failure to build solid democratic institutions were due to its “Hispanic value system” which include a mistrust of outsiders and an overemphasis on family.

    Love Dennis Prager’s lecture on “E pluribus Unim” where he talks about the same thing – how America was the first time where “blood” didn’t matter. Wherein other countries, if you weren’t “blood”, they didn’t trust you. However, in the US, familism didn’t exist. If you could do the job, you were hired, regardless of your tribe or bloodline. I find the whole “melting pot versus quilt” discussion interesting.

    Anyway – great job providing a well rounded article guys and for not settling for easy answers on a problem that clearly doesn’t have any simple solutions. Keep up the great work!

    Oh…and would be curious to hear more of Gheorghe Sarau story and how he became so successful.

  3. Pingback: Milan sẽ thể hiện một bộ mặt khác tại Champions League?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>